Discussion between Impotence & Egaladeist

Status
Not open for further replies.

Impotence

May the source be with u!
[OT]
I have created this thread so that myself and Egaldeist can continue our discussion without further disrupting rebekka

This discussion started in THIS thread
[/OT]

Spoken like a true teenager.

I don't see why my age has anything to do with this. If your trying to disregard what i say instead of actually thinking about it and creating an intelligent reply then you have definitely lost any respect i might have had for you, Richard.

Impotence said:
Comparing a computer software to a car is completely ridiculous Egaladeist, If you can find a case where someone making a mistake installing windows / general software has actually caused them physical harm or killed them then please accept my apologies. Try to some up with a decent comparison next time.

People rely upon their computer these days as much as their cars...the analogy wasn't ridiculous at all...going off the deep end by saying a mucked up computer wouldn't kill them IS ridiculous.

I believe you are mistaken on this point, people may rely on computers as much as cars but i don't believe that the vast majority (80-90%?) of people with a computer in there home rely on it for there income in any way, unless playing games, social networking sites (MySpace etc), talking to friends on IM networks and browsing the net are essential to live.

I stand by my original statement:-

"If you can find a case where someone making a mistake installing windows / general software has actually caused them physical harm or killed them then please accept my apologies"

Notice that i am talking about SOFTWARE, unlike hardware, software cannot hurt you!

Maybe you don't live on your own, work off your computer, and have children to feed...so it's not a big deal to you if someone mucks up their computer trying to follow your advice.

No, i don't live on my own (i have a flatmate) but you try living by yourself on a part time job while your doing a HND full time... I'm sure it can be done but i don't imagine it would be an enjoyable experience.

How dare you are suggest that i don't care about other people and the affects that my actions will have on them. I don't know of anyone who has 'mucked their computer up' doing what i suggested and i would NEVER suggest to anyone to do anything that would!

I'm sure you guarantee your help with the replacement of any mucked up parts...you do don't you?

This is not an issue that has ever come up and is definitely not relevant to rebekka's thread as i have not suggested at any point in that thread that she should open her computers case.

I prefer to go with the simpler, less expensive method of not telling anyone to do something that would damage there computer. In a court i may very well be liable if i suggested something that directly (and permanently) damaged a computer but everything i suggest is with good intent.

Sure it's nice to teach people, get them to learn something...but you have to have a reasonable head about you...

rebekka DID NOT come here and ask ' how do I get this crap off my computer? '
she asked ' how can I change my IP address so I don't get anymore viruses or malware '

rebekka's skill-set is obviously very low...if you'd prefer to help than direct him/her to appropriate care...then I hope you take responsibility when he/she mucks up the computer based upon your advice that he/she learns through trial n' error because you think...that's the best way to approach this particular person.

You have made this point before and I'm now asking you not to make it again, this is not constructive in any way and you are suggesting that rebekka is not able to learn, in other words you are suggesting she is stupid which is completely unfair and totally uncalled for.

I did not suggest that rebekka learns to do this through trial and error.

Hardwareforums is here to to help people do things themselves. I have the patience to help just about anyone with any problem they are having (even if i have to dictate, step by step, over the telephone or VOIP as i have done many times for friends a family, with many of them around rebekka's level of skill).

Gawd love the teenage years.

Here you go again, yet another bash at me because of my age. Grouping me with every other person of my age or applying any stereotype you may have of teenagers to me is not only wrong, its completely unfair.

I am an adult, not a teenager. If i can be held responsible for my actions in a court of law then i see no reason or justification for subjecting me to derogatory language that suggests that i am not able or mature enough to take responsibility for my own life and actions when i can be imprisoned for them.

This point is not up for debate, if you have an issue with it then thats your problem. I Don't want to hear about it.

I approach each person as I see fit...as I evaluate the situation...if I am confident that a person can fix the problem themselves and just needs direction then so be it...
but I'm not negligent in my belief that everyone is so capable.

Perhaps i have not been exposed to the cold hard reality of life for long enough, but i always try to see the best in people and will never assume that someone is not able to learn a new skill.

I do not believe that seeing the best in people and giving them the chance to learn as negligent, i would consider myself to be a bad person if i did not offer them this chance.

Your way is not only irresponsible...it borders on sheer negligence.

I do not see how it is irresponsible to offer someone the chance to learn, or why it is negligent to do so

Coming from someone i respected these words would have meant something, however coming from you they mean nothing. I do not care for your views or feelings, the only words i will listen to from you will need facts to back them up.

But that's just my opinion...I had no problem letting you help your way...grow up and stop being so offended that I help in MY OWN WAY...not your way.

I never once took offense with your method, i merely disagreed when you told rebekka that she should pay to have her computer 'repaired';-

"If your machine is infected and you don't know what you're doing ( and it's apparent that you don't ) take it to your local computer shop and have it cleaned out..."

Given that the 'local computer shop' will just reinstall windows and charge her a ridiculous amount to do it i believe that my objection was fair.

I love discussion, the more the merrier but what you claim to be "MY OWN WAY" (ie YOUR OWN WAY) is technically not your own, as it would be the 'local computer shop' that deals with it.

If you read my original post it doesn't even mention you...I offered help as I saw fit to offer it...and instead of accepting that I took the time to post my help and appreciating my opinion...

I will assume that you have made a mistake here, as i doubt you meant to say you take the time to appreciate your own opinions (that would be rather egotistical)

you seem to have a problem with the way I choose to help...

My issue is not with your help, you offered some good advice to rebekka the issue i have is that you did not even give her the chance to say if she would be comfortable installing windows, you instantly assumed that she would not be able to.

only a teenager or someone immature could be that offended by someone trying to help in their own way...grow up.

As i stated above, i do not believe that telling someone that they are not able to do something is helpful (unless what they are doing puts them in physical danger).

I also believe that i have 'grown up', unlike most people around my age i respect my responsibility (but demand my rights) and take an active interest in the world around me and will stand up for any individual or group when i believe they are not being treated fairly and i have the opportunity to do something about it.

YES this is a computer help forum...and that is EXACTLY why you should appreciate other opinions and assistance...I don't have to waste my time trying to help people, I have my own set of responsibilities...

If you truly think that helping people with whatever problems they are having is wasting your time then i do not understand why you try to help? i can only conclude that you do not believe you are wasting your time, but what are you trying to achieve?

rebekka is lucky to have a more diverse exploration of ideas...or ...maybe...
Yes, she is... although i don't know if lucky is the right word (as anyone can get help here) I'm sure she appreciates any help we offer.

you think only yours counts?
If i did, there would be no argument as i would not care what you think if i believed myself to be right all the time.

You believe you are right, i believe i am right... the idea is that we try to convince each other that we are right and *hopefully* we come to an agreement on who is right, or even decide that we are both wrong.

Obviously you're a mega expert...I should bow to your years of experience and your wall of certificates...

Gawd love the teenage years.

I'm just going to ignore that!


Just as a follow up...

it wasn't my intention of messing up this thread...I was quite willing to offer my opinion and leave it up to rebekka to choose which advice he/she wanted to follow...

Didn't i suggest that if you wanted to continue this that you should PM me or create a thread in the war zone? instead you post at least another A4 worth of text in the thread

you chose to flame the thread...because you thought/think my advice wasn't in line with your thoughts...

and that is the difference between an adult and a teenager...an adult gives people choices and doesn't assume their choice is immediately the right one...

I'm sorry but i do have to admit to laughing as i read this, surely offering to help her reinstall windows instead of telling her to get the local computer shop to do it would be giving her a choice (people already know they can pay people to fix there computer!).

By your definition, you are the teenager and i am the adult in this situation.

you...on the other hand...would rather rebekka NOT have that choice...the ability to choose between who's advice he/she wants to follow...

because...you must be right...right?

Personally, I prefer to have choices.

as i said before, rebekka already knows that she can pay someone to fix her computer... giving her a choice would be offering to help her do it herself.

By telling her that she is not able to do it, and that she should/can get the local computer shop to do it does not offer her a choice.

and what makes you so sure you are right? I believe i am right, but unlike you i seem to be able to accept that this does not necessarily mean that i am right and i am more than willing to argue my point until you change your view, or you change my view.

This is one of the reasons I don't come here very often...and why you don't have a lot of active members over 25 ( in my case over 45 )...

Obviously there are more people around 25 than 45 here (i thought you where 50 anyway), the vast majority of us grew up with computers in our living rooms and now kids are growing up with them in there bedrooms. It would not surprise me if at some point soon babies have 19" touch screens at the ends of there cots to play with and it is considered normal!

I am not saying that we are better with computers, I'm just saying there are more of us who are able to understand them because more of us are exposed to them as we grown up.

teenage attitudes

Bloody OAPs

no that was not fair, but it probably shows you how i feel when you when disregard me as a teenager.

I'm right , you're wrong...why are you helping in my thread...go find your own thread...immature BS.

Of course i think I'm right and your wrong (just as you think your right and i am wrong), I'm hardly going to think that I'm wrong and your right and try to convince you that your right am i?

I have never told anyone to find there own thread, as its not my thread to start with.

Be thankful I tried to help at all.

Now this is the immature bullshit. No one will ever really respect your if you demand it (they might fear you though) and the same goes here, no one is going to be grateful or thankful if you demand that they are.

I'm sure rebekka is grateful when people try to help her, but demanding it is out of order.
 
It is obvious that this is a waste of my time as the point seems to have completely been lost to you...

I will make this very short and simple for you...the fact is...

I posted what I thought was in the OP's best interest...I offered my opinion, my input...another opinion for the OP to ponder...another thing for the OP to take into consideration...

that is all that it should ever have been taken as...period!


Grow up.
 
So lets get this straight...

  • You try to disregard what i say due to my age
  • you suggest that i don't care how my actions affect other people
  • You claim i am unreasonable
  • You stereotype me
  • You accuse me of being negligent
  • You call me immature
  • You accuse me of being self centered
  • You take the piss out of me repeatedly
  • You look down on me for being a 'teenager'
  • You claim that i am trying to remove rebekka's choice
  • You call rebekka stupid, along with every other non geek computer user

And you don't apologize to me or rebekka, make corrections or admit mistakes or even claim that i misunderstood anything that you have said. I can only assume that you mean every word of it.

I think your the one who has to grow up
 
I hate to have to intervene on something like this, but here it is. Hardware Forums Rules And Privacy Policy <- The rules. Here's the key part:
HardwareForums Rules said:
5.) Personal attacks or other forms of disrespect are something that we don't want to see here. If you have a beef with someone, take it up with them over PM, e-mail, instant messaging, or anything else, so long as it doesn't come across these forums. Disrespect of a mod or admin or repeat offenses can affect your posting privileges. Also, any flame wars and the like that are on other message boards are not welcome here. We don't need it nor want it. Threads will be deleted for starters, but don't push your luck.
You both should know better. Egaladeist, you're a long-timer here. And Impotence, you're a news staffer, come on now. I understand that it's easy to get worked up about your opinions, especially since we have such a diverse community here. But honestly, the world is shitty enough as it is without us dragging eachother through the mud here too. If you guys want to go have at it in some dark god-forsaken alleyway of the Internet or otherwise, that's your business. But here you need to have respect for your HWF community, and keep crap like this out of everybody else's faces.

Yours truly,
-AT
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top