Caught a nasty Ubuntu Gutsy bug

megamaced

megamaced

Geek Geek Geek!
I recently upgraded my graphics card from an nVidia Geforce FX 5200 PCI to an Geforce 7200 GS PCI Express card. The major reason for this is that I wanted to use PCI-E and also the fact that the FX cards suck.

However to my dismay, I have discovered that there is a major bug with the nVidia driver and the Gutsy kernel in that the system will just freeze for no reason whatsoever. This can happen within 5 minutes or 3 hours. However IT WILL happen! It doesn't matter whether Compiz is running or my computer is sitting idle.

I've even tried installing the binary driver from nVidia's website and installing it manually but the same problem occurs.

So I've had to revert back to my FX card until Hardy Heron comes along! What a royal pain in the :swear:
 
I am not one for drifting too far away from official Ubuntu packages, but thanks anyway. That being said, I might check out your custom kernel in my test Gutsy VM at some point. I'd be interested to compare the performance.
 
Hey, you're the one who said it was broken, I only agreed.

megamaced said:
LOL, I am gonna get Mark Shuttleworth on your ass!
Click to expand...
P.S. - Please do, I'd love to sit down and have a chat with Mr. Shuttleworth. I'm willing to bet though that if he has some kind of blacklist, I'd be on it when we parted ways. ;)
 
Anti-Trend said:
Hey, you're the one who said it was broken, I only agreed.


P.S. - Please do, I'd love to sit down and have a chat with Mr. Shuttleworth. I'm willing to bet though that if he has some kind of blacklist, I'd be on it when we parted ways. ;)
Click to expand...

HAHAHA, lol, on a side note, it may just be for the 7300, as i have a 7600GT and never had a freezing issue???
 
I'd still be interested to see how it'd work using Nvidia's official Linux drivers rather than the generic Ubuntu repackage. There's a good chance it would actually work that way.
 
I honestly can't win right now...

The 7200GS freeze bug exists in Ubuntu Hardy Heron too, so I decided to cut my losses and buy an 8400GS. Ubuntu doesn't freeze anymore, so that's a good thing. But now I've caught another bug: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/compiz/+bug/194851. What's the deal with nVidia lately? I've had no issues with their products until now.

So it looks like I have the following options:

Go back to my Geforce FX5200 PCI: No problems whatsoever, but as a graphics card it just plain and simply sucks...
Use the Geforce 7200GS: and enjoy random lock ups..
Use the Geforce 8400GS: and enjoy a camp desktop...
Use the inbuilt VIA Unicrome chipset: yikes!
 
[ot]Or the 5th option - use windows and have it just 'work' teehee

*takes cover*[/ot]
 
[ot]
ferg said:
Or the 5th option - use windows and have it just 'work' teehee

*takes cover*
Click to expand...
Oh, you mean like this? Windows "just works" in the same way that influenza "just works". Not a very tempting offer. :) Besides, I don't have any of the problems experienced by Mr. Megamaced, and I am using Debian with the official NVidia drivers from nvidia.com. I suspect it may just be a problem with the way Ubuntu has packaged the drivers... much like the drivers that XP shipped with, having crippled or missing 3D support, if you recall. ;)[/ot]
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top